MI Jails Cut Costs Through Food
It’s lunchtime at the Livonia police lockup. Officer Dan Tar slips a warm, cellophane-wrapped cheeseburger and a small plastic container of lemonade through a shoebox-size slot in the bars of a cell holding a Farmington Hills woman accused of driving on a suspended license. No condiments. No straw. Story from the Detroit Free Press.
“It’s edible,” the 30-year-old, who identified herself only as Taira, said. “I expected bologna and hard bread.”
If she had been arrested elsewhere in metro Detroit, her fare would have varied from a heated frozen meal in Troy to a peanut butter and jelly sandwich in Detroit.
Like Livonia’s lockup, jails around Michigan are trying to save money on the cost of prisoner food, with many replacing restaurant fare with simpler meals to save money and manpower. In May, Wayne County privatized its jail food program in an effort to save $2.5 million a year. The Michigan Department of Corrections is conducting pilot programs in some prisons to cut costs, with some sites showing 30% savings. The programs may go statewide Oct. 1.
“These are people we have locked up,” Harper Woods Police Chief Randolph Skotarczyk said. “It can’t be bread and water.”
Prisoner food is hard to trim out of city, county and state budgets, but governments are trying to save. In a Michigan Department of Corrections cost-saving plan that could go statewide this fall, steps include standardizing menus and ordering food in bulk, spokesman John Cordell said.
The programs, in part, stem from the Michigan auditor general’s 2008 audit of prisoner food services that states the corrections department should consider additional ways to reduce the costs of providing prisoner meals.
Detroit faces cost cutting for jail food, too. Detroit Police Department spokesman John Roach said the 2010-11 budget has $170,000 for meals — $180,000 less than this year. He said the mayor’s office is working to address the matter.
He also said Detroit is trying to enter into an agreement with Wayne County to house detainees — a move that would be better for detainees and for police, which could return cops to the street and “satisfy a very big portion of our (federal) consent decree.”
Macomb County will spend before it saves. On Thursday, county commissioners may approve a nearly $1.5-million contract to renovate the county jail’s aged kitchen, which closed in the fall because of mold in freezers. The work could be done by Nov. 1, allowing inmates to return to eating regular hot meals instead of brown-bag ones.
“When citizens take on the responsibility of incarcerating people for criminal behavior, they also take on the responsibility of caring for them,” Cordell said.
What inmates are eating
Many metro area law-enforcement agencies have stopped using restaurants for detainee food, with Ferndale switching to a vendor that delivers prepackaged meals. Ferndale Capt. Timothy Collins said the agency has cut its meal cost by at least 30%.“At one point, we were using three different restaurants. Certainly, it’s not cost-effective,” he said.
The Kitchen Inc. in Madison Heights makes weekly deliveries to the Ferndale lockup of freshly prepared meals that can be frozen and heated in the microwave.
Company President Bob Watson said food deliveries also are made to lockups in Southfield Madison Heights and Royal Oak. Most get the same type of food: breakfast sandwich (such as sausage and egg) and orange juice for breakfast, and a pizza slice or hamburger and prepackaged juice for lunch and dinner.
Harper Woods, which budgets about $1,600 a month for prisoner meals, and some of the Grosse Pointes — such as Gross Pointe Park and Grosse Pointe Shores — still use restaurants for prisoner food. Pointes’ officers pick up the grub, whether it’s a restaurant meal or a sandwich from a gas station.
Rex’s Kelly Deli in Eastpointe delivers prisoner meals to Harper Woods police, saving officers time. The reduced-priced fare usually is a bowl of cereal for breakfast, a hamburger for lunch and piece of fried chicken and vegetables and salad for dinner, owner Rex Zink said, adding that he also accommodates special diets “the few and far between” times they are needed.
Nutrition and other concerns
Unlike county jails, which are inspected by the state corrections department, authorities said no agency oversees local lockups that usually house prisoners for up to 72 hours. Detroit is under a federal consent decree requiring quality, balanced nutrition.Like at county jails, officials at local lockups provide three meals a day. Some lockups ask prisoners whether they have allergies or special diets, such as vegan or kosher, but said that is rarely an issue. Many keep orange juice on hand for diabetics.
Rana Elmir, communications director with the American Civil Liberties Union of Michigan, said “prisoner food must be in accordance with the Eighth Amendment’s ban on cruel and unusual punishment — for instance, an inmate cannot be forced to eat food that he/she is allergic to or that is contaminated — and the First Amendment’s freedom of religion claim, which demands prisons supply inmates with food following their deeply held religious requirements.”
The ACLU is involved in a federal case that asks, in part, that Michigan prisons provide Muslim inmates halal food and allow them to participate in two annual feasts recognized as high holy days in Islam.
What it costs to feed prisoners
Warren Police Commissioner William Dwyer said his agency budgeted $7,500 for prisoner food for a year. In September, it stopped serving danishes for breakfast and started handing out ham and cheese sandwiches, which also are served for lunch and dinner, Lt. Louis Galasso said. He said the move was made to save money and provide more nutritious meals.Galasso said it’s rare for someone to be in the lockup long enough to get three meals. Most get two meals before being arraigned and released on bond or sent to the county jail. “The more choices you afford someone, the more complicated it gets,” he said.
While Livonia officers hand out wrapped danishes for breakfast or hamburgers or chicken sandwiches for lunch and dinner, those in Warren remove the wrapper and hand the sandwich to the prisoner on a paper towel. That’s to help prevent items from being stuffed into cell toilets to make them overflow. Neither lockup provides condiments, which can be smeared on walls and windows.
Livonia Capt. Robert Nenciarini said a May 27 vendor bill was $314 for cases of drinks, danishes and 150 sandwiches. Food is ordered every week to 10 days, putting the annual prisoner meal cost just over $16,000.
In Sterling Heights, a local market makes and delivers ham and cheese or turkey and cheese bagel sandwiches that are frozen and unthawed. Orange juice or coffee is provided. A pastry is given for breakfast, Lt. Luke Riley said. He said the budgeted cost for meals has dropped from $8,000 in 2007-08 to $6,500 in 2010-11 to reflect actual food bills.
“It’s decent and it fits the bill,” he said of the fare. “We’re not in the Hyatt Regency.”
No one ever said life was easy behind bars, but it has become a bit more stressful for inmates in the Macomb County Jail. Story reported in the
State Prisoners in Oregon will have to make do without soda pop,
The Union of Solicitor General Employees (USGE), a component union of the Public Service Alliance of Canada (PSAC), is launching a campaign to stop the federal government’s plan to close six farming operations run by Correctional Service Canada (CSC) over the next two years.
The cash-strapped Oklahoma Department of Corrections has been able to offset the cost of feeding nearly 18,500 inmates daily because of an agricultural program that gives prisoners valuable skills, agency officials said.
Prisoners in Georgia are now going without lunch three days in a row — the Department of Corrections recently eliminated midday meals on Fridays in addition to weekends.
Sheriff Joe Arpaio said on Friday that inmates will have to pay for better tasting food served in the Maricopa County AZ Sheriff’s Office jail system.
UN Deputy Envoy, Ms. Henrietta Mensa-Bonsu has described an agricultural pilot project for inmates at the Liberian National Palace of Corrections “as a bold step towards institutionalizing active programs for rehabilitation of inmates.”
For the first time in nearly 20 years, Linn County OR Jail has begun serving inmates a cold rather than a hot breakfast in order to save money.
State Rep. John Proos said Gov. Granholm is putting public safety at risk through a state corrections budget that releases prisoners to make up for budget shortfalls.
Adams County PA will soon get into the culinary business – in jail. Starting in June, the county will be providing its own food service at Adams County Prison. The current contractor, Aramark Food Services, chose to cancel its contract with the county effective June 18,
Correctional Service Canada’s (CSC) recent announcement that it plans to cut farm operations at six prisons, two of which in Kingston, Ontario, has raised eyebrows in some circles.
Vermont inmates who use utensils to throw bodily waste or food can’t be placed on a special diet without first going through a disciplinary process, a divided Vermont Supreme Court ruled Friday.
Feeding inmates, tending to their medical needs and a possibility that crime could increase this year were all topics Stephens County OK Sheriff Wayne McKinney shared with county commissioners this week,
The agency that runs Louisiana’s prisons is trying to cut costs by turning kitchen grease into biodiesel fuel.
The director of the Iowa Department of Corrections says it would be a mistake to delay several prison construction projects, despite a $700-million shortfall in the state budget.
Albany County NY lawmakers, in what was described as a first of its kind policy in the region, approved a measure Monday night to buy locally-grown food for the jail and nursing home.
Florida is now coping with the effects of a failed and expensive food-privatization venture.
Recent Comments